| Round 1 | Round 2 | Round 3 | Round 4 | Round 5 | |||||
| MELO | F John Tavares | MELO | D Bobby Sanguinetti | MELO | G Nikolai Khabibulin | CRUZ | F Todd Bertuzzi | MELO | D Matt Hunwick |
| OG | F Matt Duchene | OG | F Jamie Langenbrunner | OG | D Rob Blake | OG | F Andrew Ladd | OG | F Alex Burrows |
| DUNC | D Victor Hedman | DUNC | F Jiri Tlusty | DUNC | F Nikolai Zherdev | DUNC | F Teddy Purcell | DUNC | F Nathan Gerbe |
| RICK | F Evander Kane | CRUZ | D John Carlson | CRUZ | D James Wisniewski | CRUZ | D Keith Ballard | CRUZ | D Matt Carle |
| BEDS | F Colin Wilson | BES | F Ryane Clowe | CRUZ | F Nik Antropov | BES | F Ryan Stoa | BES | F Scott Hartnell |
| BEDS | D Matt Gilroy | BEDS | F James Sheppard | RICK | F Ryan Kesler | BEDS | F Slava Kozlov | BEDS | F Tomas Plekanec |
| RICK | F Mikael Backlund | DUNC | G Vesa Toskala | CRUZ | D Jonathan Ericsson | PF | D Anton Babchuk | MELO | F Daymond Langkow |
| LIMA | F Josh Bailey | DUNC | D Fedor Tyutin | LIMA | F David Backes | OG | F Todd White | MELO | F Martin Erat |
| DUNC | F Andrei Kostitsyn | BUTS | G Mike Smith | RICK | F Fabian Brunnstrom | BUTS | F Justin Williams | RICK | F Brandon Dubinsky |
| RICK | D John-Michael Liles | RICK | D Andrej Sekera | LIMA | F Artem Anisimov | CRUZ | F Jamie Benn | RICK | G Jonas Gustavsson |
| Round 6 | Round 7 | Round 8 | Round 9 | Round 10 | |||||
| MELO | D Mark Giordano | LIMA | D Cody Franson | MELO | F Chuck Kobasew | MELO | F Matt Stajan | LIMA | F Erik Cole |
| LIMA | F Shawn Horcoff | OG | D Willie Mitchell | OG | G Chris Mason | OG | D Mathieu Schneider | OG | D Aaron Johnson |
| DUNC | G Jon Quick | DUNC | F Mike Knuble | DUNC | F T.J. Hensick | DUNC | D Johnny Oduya | DUNC | G Chris Osgood |
| CRUZ | F Sergei Samsonov | CRUZ | F Bill Guerin | CRUZ | F Sergei Shirokov | CRUZ | F Luca Caputi | CRUZ | F Brendan Morrison |
| BES | F Ryan Smyth | BES | D Ryan Ellis | BES | F Andrew Ebbett | BES | F Jonathan Cheechoo | BES | D Ron Hainsey |
| BEDS | D Pavel Kubina | BEDS | F Oscar Moller | BEDS | F Torrey Mitchell | BEDS | D Wade Redden | BEDS | F Brian Rolston |
| PF | F Jordan Eberle | PF | F Magnus Paajarvi-Svensson | PF | F Nazem Kadri | PF | F Peter Holland | PF | G Rick DiPietro |
| MELO | F Brooks Laich | LIMA | G Brian Elliott | LIMA | D Tyler Myers | LIMA | F Chris Drury | LIMA | D Christian Ehrhoff |
| BUTS | D Andrej Meszaros | BUTS | D Filip Kuba | BUTS | F R.J. Umberger | BUTS | G Jimmy Howard | BUTS | D Trevor Daley |
| MELO | F Eric Tangradi | PF | F Brayden Schenn | RICK | D Kevin Shattenkirk | RICK | G Craig Anderson | RICK | F Martin Hanzal |
| Round 11 | Round 12 | Round 13 | Round 14 | Round 15 | |||||
| MELO | D Anton Stralman | MELO | F Mikael Samuelsson | MELO | D Jamie McBain | MELO | F Guillaume Latendresse | MELO | D Marc-Andre Bergeron |
| OG | F Rob Schremp | OG | D Mattias Ohlund | OG | D Matt Pelech | OG | F Marek Svatos | OG | G Jose Theodore |
| DUNC | F James Neal | DUNC | D Michal Rozsival | LIMA | F Nick Foligno | DUNC | F Steve Downie | DUNC | F Tyler Bozak |
| MELO | F Alexei Ponikarovsky | CRUZ | G Jacob Markstrom | MELO | F Steve Ott | CRUZ | F Mike Fisher | CRUZ | D Jonathan Blum |
| BES | F Cal O'Reilly | BES | D Oliver Ekman-Larsson | BES | F Christopher Higgins | BES | F Martins Karsums | BES | F Ryan Shannon |
| BEDS | D Tom Poti | BEDS | F Jason Blake | BEDS | F Darren Helm | BEDS | G Antti Niemi | BEDS | G Ray Emery |
| PF | F Tuomo Ruutu | PF | F Pavol Demitra | PF | F Rich Peverley | PF | F Cory Stillman | PF | F Ilya Zubov |
| LIMA | F Robert Nilsson | LIMA | G Jean-Sebastien Giguere | LIMA | D Ville Koistinen | LIMA | F Daniel Cleary | LIMA | F Frans Nielsen |
| BUTS | D Carlo Colaiacovo | BUTS | F Robert Lang | BUTS | D Chris Butler | BUTS | D Sami Lepisto | BUTS | F Jordan Schroeder |
| RICK | F Lars Eller | RICK | F Ryan Callahan | RICK | D Dmitri Kulikov | RICK | D Kyle Quincey | RICK | G Ondrej Pavelec |
| Round 16 | Round 17 | Round 18 | |||||||
| BES | F Dmitri Kugryshev | BES | G Cory Schneider | PF | F Mark Recchi | ||||
| PF | F Scott Glennie | PF | G Corey Crawford | BUTS | F Drayson Bowman | ||||
| BUTS | G Michal Neuvirth | BUTS | F Rod Brind'Amour | Draft Date: Sept 6, 2009 | |||||
| R - # | MELO | R - # | OG | R - # | DUNC | R - # | RICK | R - # | BEDS |
| 1-1 | F John Tavares | 1-2 | F Matt Duchene | 1-3 | D Victor Hedman | 1-4 | F Evander Kane | 1-5 | F Colin Wilson |
| 2-1 | D Bobby Sanguinetti | 2-2 | F Jamie Langenbrunner | 1-9 | F Andrei Kostitsyn | 1-7 | F Mikael Backlund | 1-6 | D Matt Gilroy |
| 3-1 | G Nikolai Khabibulin | 3-2 | D Rob Blake | 2-3 | F Jiri Tlusty | 1-10 | D John-Michael Liles | 2-6 | F James Sheppard |
| 5-1 | D Matt Hunwick | 4-2 | F Andrew Ladd | 2-7 | G Vesa Toskala | 2-10 | D Andrej Sekera | 4-6 | F Slava Kozlov |
| 5-7 | F Daymond Langkow | 4-8 | F Todd White | 2-8 | D Fedor Tyutin | 3-6 | F Ryan Kesler | 5-6 | F Tomas Plekanec |
| 5-8 | F Martin Erat | 5-2 | F Alex Burrows | 3-3 | F Nikolai Zherdev | 3-9 | F Fabian Brunnstrom | 6-6 | D Pavel Kubina |
| 6-1 | D Mark Giordano | 7-2 | D Willie Mitchell | 4-3 | F Teddy Purcell | 5-9 | F Brandon Dubinsky | 7-6 | F Oscar Moller |
| 6-8 | F Brooks Laich | 8-2 | G Chris Mason | 5-3 | F Nathan Gerbe | 5-10 | G Jonas Gustavsson | 8-6 | F Torrey Mitchell |
| 6-10 | F Eric Tangradi | 9-2 | D Mathieu Schneider | 6-3 | G Jon Quick | 8-10 | D Kevin Shattenkirk | 9-6 | D Wade Redden |
| 8-1 | F Chuck Kobasew | 10-2 | D Aaron Johnson | 7-3 | F Mike Knuble | 9-10 | G Craig Anderson | 10-6 | F Brian Rolston |
| 9-1 | F Matt Stajan | 11-2 | F Rob Schremp | 8-3 | F T.J. Hensick | 10-10 | F Martin Hanzal | 11-6 | D Tom Poti |
| 11-1 | D Anton Stralman | 12-2 | D Mattias Ohlund | 9-3 | D Johnny Oduya | 11-10 | F Lars Eller | 12-6 | F Jason Blake |
| 11-4 | F Alexei Ponikarovsky | 13-2 | D Matt Pelech | 10-3 | G Chris Osgood | 12-10 | F Ryan Callahan | 13-6 | F Darren Helm |
| 12-1 | F Mikael Samuelsson | 14-2 | F Marek Svatos | 11-3 | F James Neal | 13-10 | D Dmitri Kulikov | 14-6 | G Antti Niemi |
| 13-1 | D Jamie McBain | 15-2 | G Jose Theodore | 12-3 | D Michal Rozsival | 14-10 | D Kyle Quincey | 15-6 | G Ray Emery |
| 13-4 | F Steve Ott | 14-3 | F Steve Downie | 15-10 | G Ondrej Pavelec | ||||
| 14-1 | F Guillaume Latendresse | 15-3 | F Tyler Bozak | ||||||
| 15-1 | D Marc-Andre Bergeron | ||||||||
| R - # | LIMA | R - # | CRUZ | R - # | BES | R - # | BUTS | R - # | PF |
| 1-8 | F Josh Bailey | 2-4 | D John Carlson | 2-5 | F Ryane Clowe | 2-9 | G Mike Smith | 4-7 | D Anton Babchuk |
| 3-8 | F David Backes | 3-4 | D James Wisniewski | 4-5 | F Ryan Stoa | 4-9 | F Justin Williams | 6-7 | F Jordan Eberle |
| 3-10 | F Artem Anisimov | 3-5 | F Nik Antropov | 5-5 | F Scott Hartnell | 6-9 | D Andrej Meszaros | 7-7 | F Magnus Paajarvi-Svensson |
| 6-2 | F Shawn Horcoff | 3-7 | D Jonathan Ericsson | 6-5 | F Ryan Smyth | 7-9 | D Filip Kuba | 7-10 | F Brayden Schenn |
| 7-1 | D Cody Franson | 4-1 | F Todd Bertuzzi | 7-5 | D Ryan Ellis | 8-9 | F R.J. Umberger | 8-7 | F Nazem Kadri |
| 7-8 | G Brian Elliott | 4-4 | D Keith Ballard | 8-5 | F Andrew Ebbett | 9-9 | G Jimmy Howard | 9-7 | F Peter Holland |
| 8-8 | D Tyler Myers | 4-10 | F Jamie Benn | 9-5 | F Jonathan Cheechoo | 10-9 | D Trevor Daley | 10-7 | G Rick DiPietro |
| 9-8 | F Chris Drury | 5-4 | D Matt Carle | 10-5 | D Ron Hainsey | 11-9 | D Carlo Colaiacovo | 11-7 | F Tuomo Ruutu |
| 10-1 | F Erik Cole | 6-4 | F Sergei Samsonov | 11-5 | F Cal O'Reilly | 12-9 | F Robert Lang | 12-7 | F Pavol Demitra |
| 10-8 | D Christian Ehrhoff | 7-4 | F Bill Guerin | 12-5 | D Oliver Ekman-Larsson | 13-9 | D Chris Butler | 13-7 | F Rich Peverley |
| 11-8 | F Robert Nilsson | 8-4 | F Sergei Shirokov | 13-5 | F Christopher Higgins | 14-9 | D Sami Lepisto | 14-7 | F Cory Stillman |
| 12-8 | G Jean-Sebastien Giguere | 9-4 | F Luca Caputi | 14-5 | F Martins Karsums | 15-9 | F Jordan Schroeder | 15-7 | F Ilya Zubov |
| 13-3 | F Nick Foligno | 10-4 | F Brendan Morrison | 15-5 | F Ryan Shannon | 16-3 | G Michal Neuvirth | 16-2 | F Scott Glennie |
| 13-8 | D Ville Koistinen | 12-4 | G Jacob Markstrom | 16-1 | F Dmitri Kugryshev | 17-3 | F Rod Brind'Amour | 17-2 | G Corey Crawford |
| 14-8 | F Daniel Cleary | 14-4 | F Mike Fisher | 17-1 | G Cory Schneider | 18-2 | F Drayson Bowman | 18-1 | F Mark Recchi |
| 15-8 | F Frans Nielsen | 15-4 | D Jonathan Blum |